PSYCHOTHERAPY BLOG
Having trained as a yoga teacher and as a psychotherapist and counsellor, I’ve been particularly interested in the growing […] Read more...
Dear Professor Bond,
Re: Proposed ethical framework – webinar two: supervision
In my letter of 11th July I suggested that the current ‘principle-based’ framework is perfectly adequate, particularly if embedded within a Relational Ethic of Care. I therefore regard the proposed return to a duties (rules by another name) based framework as misguided and likely to have unfortunate consequences. In this letter I address the second webinar on supervision, with reference to the notes on the website as well as your brief article in Therapy Today (June, 2014, pp49).
The website document is entitled “Supervision – enhancing accountability requirements”. In it you state that four “adjustments” are needed to the existing framework “in order to take account of:
- Putting the client first
- Supporting the practitioner to be trustworthy from the viewpoints of clients
- Ensuring that both supervisee and supervisor satisfy the ‘duties’ discussed in the previous webinar in ways appropriate to their roles and responsibilities
- Clarifying and updating accountability requirements in response to current legal and professional governance requirements
You then invite discussion and feedback on nine points arising from the above.
I will address each of these nine points in turn.
1. How ought the role of supervisor be adapted – if at all – to support practitioners in putting their clients first?
People become therapists and counsellors (and coaches) because they have a desire to be helpful to people in need. “Putting clients first” is therefore a fundamental part of what it means to be a therapist (from now on I will use the term ‘therapist’ or ‘practitioner’ to refer to therapists, counsellors and coaches).
Supervision is widely accepted as having three main functions: supportive, formative and normative (Proctor, 2008), to help the practitioner to be the best they can be – in the service of the client’s wellbeing! So the therapist is ‘supported’ (or cared for) in their work, so that they in turn can care for their clients. Sometimes this includes suggesting to the therapist that they may want want to return to personal therapy – if, for example, the issues of the client triggers unresolved issues of their own (principle of self-care). The aim of the formative function is to help supervisees learn from their experience and identify possible areas where further training is desirable. The normative function helps the practitioner to work to a high professional standard. This may involve pointing out blind spots and help the supervisee to rectify these. Ethical issues clearly do arise, but in my twenty-odd years of providing supervision I have found that a considered reflection on the ethical principles, within a relational and caring ethic is sufficient to help supervisor and supervisee to come to a decision that puts the wellbeing of the client first (van Ooijen, 2013:188-195).
2. How will the application of duties impact on supervisory functions and processes from the viewpoint of both supervisor and supervisee?
Reflection on practice requires supervisees to feel safe and supported so that they can be honest about all aspects of their work. A shift from a principles-based to ‘duties-based’ ethic may reduce ethical thinking to rules following and checking instead of careful ethical reflection. The role of the supervisor is likely to be perceived (by both supervisor and supervisee) as one of ‘policing’; as a result the supervisory relationship, as well as the quality of supervision, will suffer – with possible detrimental effects on clients.
3. In particular, what do you consider to be the implication for supervision arising from the ethical significance given to: i) trust in practitioners, ii) showing respect for clients; iii) building an appropriate relationship with clients; iv) maintaining integrity; v) demonstrating accountability and candour
The current ethical framework includes the following principles:
i) Being trustworthy: honouring the trust placed in the practitioner
ii) Autonomy: respect for the client’s right to be self-governing
iii) Beneficence: promoting the client’s well-being
iv) Non-maleficence: avoiding harm to the client
v) Justice: fair and impartial treatment of all clients and the provision of adequate services
vi) Self-respect: fostering the practitioner’s self-knowledge and care for self
It seems clear that the current framework already covers four of the above ‘duties’ – as follows:
Being trustworthy – included in principle of ‘being trustworthy’
Showing respect for clients – included in principle of autonomy (as well as beneficence)
Building an appropriate relationship with clients – included in principles of beneficence and non-maleficence
Maintaining integrity – included in principles of being trustworthy, beneficence and non-maleficence
‘Demonstrating accountability and candour’- qualified professionals are already accountable for their actions; (for trainees see point 4). ‘Candour’ is introduced as ‘a new duty’. However, candour refers to the quality of being open and honest – surely this is already included within the principle of ‘being trustworthy’.
4. How ought ethical responsibilities be divided between supervisors, supervisee’s colleagues, employers and trainers? What will be gained or lost if the supervisor is expected to work collaboratively with others holding responsibility for oversight of the supervisee’s work, particularly to protect client safety and practitioner effectiveness? What are the implications for the supervision of practitioners working alone?
This point refers mainly to the ‘normative’ function of supervision. Each qualified practitioner carries the ethical responsibility for their own work. As an experienced practitioner I consult my supervisor, who helps me reflect on my work, but I am responsible for that work, not my supervisor. However, if any one of us becomes aware that a colleague or supervisee is working in a way that contravenes clients’ well-being this needs to be addressed with the practitioner and (if the situation persists) taken to their employer and/or professional organisation.
For student practitioners there needs to be agreement between placement managers, supervisors and trainers. For example, if a supervisor is worried about the competence of a student practitioner this needs to be addressed with the student, the agency and the trainers. It would clearly be in contravention of the principles of ‘beneficence’ and ‘trustworthiness’, for example, if a supervisor would give a student a good report if they thought that the person was not functioning at the expected level.
5. What are the obstacles or distractions for supervisee to putting clients first that could be appropriate addressed in supervision?
As stated in my answer to point 1 above, the well being of clients is our raison d’etre and already included in the principles of beneficene and non-maleficence.
6. Ought there to be any differences between the ethical requirements for the supervision of trainee practitioners and suitably qualified/ experienced / registered practitioners?
I discussed this under point 4. I also want to make the point that trainees often need more supervision than experienced practitioners. Trainees are still learning, which means that the formative function of supervision has more emphasis. It would be in contravention of the principle of beneficence to give trainees such a high client load that they are unable to reflect on each client in depth during supervision. The customary one and a half hours of supervision a month are very unlikely to be sufficient for trainees!
7. Are there any undesirable consequences of these proposed shifts in ethical emphasis that ought to be explicitly guarded against?
I fear that this focus on ‘duties’ and ‘division of ethical responsibilities’ will shift attention away from the ethical responsibilities we all have – as enshrined in the current framework. People may become concerned with ‘am I doing everything according to what the BACP wants’, rather than reflecting on ‘what is best’ in ‘this’ situation for ‘this client’.
8. ‘Putting the client first’ creates two distinct foci of responsibility for the supervisor – responsibility to the supervisee’s clients – typically members of the public – and to the supervisee as the supervisor’s client. To whom does the supervisor owe ethical priority if these responsibilities conflict? Ought the Ethical Framework to include guidance on this?
Where is the conflict? As a supervisor it is part of my role to help the supervisee to work in accordance with the six ethical principles as set out in the current ethical framework (see page 2). In your article in Therapy Today you give the example of a supervisee being so troubled by what a client is bringing that it threatens their mental well-being and/or “is having adverse effects on their ability to function with other clients or other aspects of life”. If a supervisee is affected to the extent you suggest, they are very unlikely to be capable of working well with that particular client (beneficence) and may even be causing harm (non-maleficence). Also, practitioners should not be allocated clients that are beyond their capability or experience.
In private practice, the therapist herself is responsible for not putting her own well being at risk (principle of self care). However, if the supervisee does need to discontinue working with the client to safeguard their own well being, it is crucial to discuss the ‘how’ of this in supervision, so that the client is not harmed (principle of non-maleficence). Also, it is clearly important that an experienced person is available to take over who is capable of processing all that happened with the client. I do not think that it is good practice for this person to be the clinical supervisor. The client deserves a fresh start, so that they can tell their story and what happened from their perspective, to a person whose views are uncontaminated by what has transpired (principle of beneficence).
I also want to make a few points about the above statement that a supervisor has ‘responsibility to the supervisee’s client’. As a supervisor I am responsible to the supervisee for the quality of the supervision, I am not responsibility for the quality of the therapy, how can I be when I am not the one delivering it? Clinical supervision is a collaborative activity where supervisor and supervisee reflect deeply on the supervisee’s work, to enable them to be the best practitioner they can be.
Clinical supervision is not line management; the two roles should be discharged by different people. The line manager can be held accountable for the actions of their staff, the clinical supervisor cannot. However, the clinical supervisor does have a responsibility that is not discharged simply by collaboratively working with the supervisee, nor by telling a supervisee that something they are doing is unethical. For example, if despite all the reflection and collaboration a supervisee persists in being unethical, I, as the clinical supervisor, have a responsibility to do something about it, and this responsibility goes beyond the client in question. In this particular case the clinical supervisor is responsible to:
the particular client and all future clients of this supervisee
the organisation within which the supervisee is working
the profession
society
and, in case of trainees, to the trainers/training organisation.
(principle of non-maleficence)
Also, as I already stated under point 4 and 6, if a training supervisor does not think that a trainee has achieved the level of competence to be expected of a professional practitioner it is their responsibility to make this clear to all the above. All this should be part of the initial contract between supervisor, supervisee, and other parties as outlined above (principle of non-maleficence).
9. Ought clients to be routinely informed about the identity of the supervisor? Ought clients to have the right to communicate with the supervisor when they have serious concerns that they have not been able to address satisfactorily with the supervisee and no alternative provision for reporting concerns has been made?
My answer to both these questions is a resounding ‘no’!
Like counselling and psychotherapy, clinical supervision should be a protected space where supervisees feel safe enough to talk about all aspects of their work. Whereas it is good practice to inform clients where they might take possible complaints, that person should not be the clinical supervisor, but an impartial person or persons without prior knowledge of the situation.
To conclude, the proposed changes give an impression of an unacknowledged agenda of managerialism, confusion between line management and clinical supervision, and a wish to turn clinical supervision into something not unlike quality assurance. All appear to be due to a regrettable lack of trust in counsellors and therapists as professional people, who want to be the best practitioners they can be to the benefit of their clients. I see this proposal as a retrograde step that is likely to damage the professions of counselling and psychotherapy.
Yours sincerely,
Dr Els van Ooijen
References:
Proctor, G. (2008) Group Supervision. A guide to creative practice. London: Sage Publications.
Van Ooijen, E. (2013) Clinical Supervision Made Easy. A creative and relational approach for the helping professions. Ross on Wye: PCCS Books