PSYCHOTHERAPY BLOG
Having trained as a yoga teacher and as a psychotherapist and counsellor, I’ve been particularly interested in the growing […] Read more...
Dear Professor Bond,
Re: Proposed ethical framework – webinar one
First of all I would like to express my appreciation of your (and the BACP’s) generosity, energy and commitment regarding the proposed changes to the ethical framework. I also welcome the opportunity for myself as a practitioner to comment on the proposals, as in order to function authentically I need to be in complete agreement with my professional organisation’s ethical framework. This is an important issue and I have therefore taken some time to reflect on the proposals and will address the content of the three webinars separately.
Regarding webinar one, I will address the following issues:
- the rationale for the proposed change
- the criticism made of the existing framework
- the proposed change from a principle-based ethic to one based on duties
I will deal with each of these issues in turn before suggesting how the existing framework and some of the proposed changes may be combined within a larger relational ethic of care.
The rationale for the proposed change
You state that the climate has changed in terms of knowledge regarding what works, the addition of coaches to the BACP, the impact of new technologies, recent scandals within health and social care and the Jimmy Savile case.
Your argument appears to be that as the climate has changed, the existing principle-based code is not sufficient and we must therefore adopt a framework based on duties. I take issue both with the premises and the conclusions of this argument -
Increased knowledge regarding what works.
This is a rather global statement that as it stands is meaningless. For example, what is the nature of this knowledge? What is the quality of the research upon which it is based? What is meant by ‘what works’? In any case, as ‘beneficence’ is one of the current ethical framework’s principles – would that not already imply adopting ‘what works’?
The inclusion of coaches within the BACP
As coaches, counsellors and psychotherapists are all concerned with helping people addressing issues and problems, it is not clear why the inclusion of coaches should make a difference to the ethical framework.
Implications of new technologies
Whereas working ethically whilst using new technologies clearly needs to be thought through carefully, it is not clear why this way of working should differ so significantly as to necessitate a new ethical framework.
Scandals in health and social care and the Jimmy Savile case
Regarding the above there may well be a need in these areas to tighten up certain practices and to educate the public regarding what they have a right to expect. However, there is an unstated assumption here that a framework such as the one proposed would have prevented these scandals from occurring. This argument is flawed: all helping professions have ethical codes and everyone knows that mistreating and abusing fellow human beings is wrong. Also, the scandals within health and social care are very different to the activities of predatory paedophiles such as Savile and others. People such as Savile are not going to cease to exist through the adoption of a duties based ethical framework by counsellors and psychotherapists.
Scandals within the NHS have multiple causes, such as a ‘chronic under resourcing’ (Ballett and Campling, 2011) and the pressure to do ever more with less, all of which lead to pressurised, overworked staff who themselves feel unvalued and uncared for. Ballett and Campling (2011:3) point out that what is needed here is a change in the culture to include a sense of ‘kinship and compassionate relationship between the skilled physician and the patient’. They stress that the people working within health and social care themselves need to feel that they are treated with compassion and kindness, so that they in turn can treat those in their care similarly.
Your criticism of the existing framework
You state that it is addressed to practitioners rather than clients. At the same time, however, you appear to propose two versions of the proposed framework – one for practitioners and one for clients. This could, of course, also be done with the existing framework. You also state that there is a need for a fuller discourse across professional boundaries. Again this does not seem enough of a reason in itself for such a complete change as the one proposed.
Proposed change from a ‘principle-based’ ethic to one based on ‘duties’.
You state that the current ethical framework is now fifteen years old and thereby imply that that is enough of a reason to discard it. Why? After all regarding ethics we still refer to Aristotle, Kant and so on, even though principles they espoused are now very old.
In my view, the shift from a ‘rule-based’ to a ‘principles-based’ ethic was a positive development. It signalled that counselling and psychotherapy were maturing professions that no longer treated their members as subjects, but as mature professionals, capable of making decisions based on ethical reflection and taking responsibility for their own conduct. I fear that a return to a different ethic may stop ethical thinking and reflection and result in practitioners simply doing as they are told. I know that this is not your intention, but I fear that it is a likely consequence.
Lastly, I believe it to be a category mistake to see ethics as a set of duties. After all, where do duties come from if they are not based on certain agreed principles, either implicitly or explicitly?
A proposed alternative
Many of the duties you propose may be derived from one or more of the current framework’s ethical principles. For example, the proposed duty of ‘working to professional standards’ follows naturally from the principles of beneficence and non-maleficence. At the same time, a purely principle-based ethic has been criticised by feminist philosophers (Gilligan, Noddings, Slote) as advocating a masculine stance that does not take into account a more feminine emphasis on context. I should therefore like to propose the adoption of a Relational Ethic of Care as an overarching framework that includes a principle-based approach (see van Ooijen, 2013:163-174). Working within such an ethic involves a commitment to high standards, expertise and best practice as well as an intersubjective stance that pays attention to the client’s as well as the therapist’s phenomenological experience – what Mearns and Cooper (2005:xii) call ‘working at relational depth.’
A relational ethic implies that work with clients should always be seen in context. Therefore an attempt to set down specific duties (or rules by another name) that apply to everyone is problematic, as people and their contexts will differ. As Pauls and James (2005:36) state, ‘…with relational ethics, from the perspective of mutual respect, we focus on who we are rather than what we do, that is a way of being rather than a mode of decision making’.
My proposal therefore is that we retain the principles from the current framework, but frame them within a relational and caring ethic. Rather than setting ‘duties’ in tablets of stone, we can then develop a set of guidelines that indicate how certain practices flow naturally from them. In other words, rather than setting specific duties in tablets of stone, it would remain the professional practitioner’s ethical responsibility to decide the extent to which the guidelines apply in their particular context, based on the ethical principles and the overarching relational ethic of care.
Once again, thank you for offering practitioners the opportunity to comment on these proposals. I really appreciate being able to do so.
Yours sincerely,
Dr Els van Ooijen
References:
Ballett, J. and Campling, P. (2011) Intelligent Kindness: Reforming the Culture of Healthcare. London: The Royal College of Psychiatrists.
Gilligan, C. (1982) In a Different Voice. Harvard: Harvard University Press.
Mearns, D. and Cooper, M. (2005) Working at relational depth in counselling and psychotherapy. London: Sage.
Noddings, N. (2013) Caring: A relational approach to ethics and moral education. Univ. of /California Press.
Slote, M. (2007) The ethics of care and empathy. London: Routledge.
Van Ooijen, E. (2013) Clinical Supervision Made Easy. A creative and relational approach for the helping professions. Ross on Wye: PCCS Books